Answer 10 questions about your case. We will identify common overcharging patterns and red flags to discuss with your attorney.
All answers are processed locally in your browser. Nothing is stored or transmitted.
Select the primary charge category. If you face multiple types, pick the most serious one.
First-time offenders are frequently overcharged because prosecutors assume they will accept any deal out of fear.
Prosecutors sometimes add assault or great bodily injury enhancements even when injuries are minor or nonexistent.
Charge stacking is one of the most common overcharging tactics. For example, a single altercation might be charged as assault, battery, criminal threats, and false imprisonment -- four counts for one event.
Many California offenses are "wobblers" -- they can be charged as either felonies or misdemeanors. DAs routinely charge the felony version to increase bargaining leverage.
Enhancements can add years or decades to a sentence. Common enhancements include gang allegations (186.22 PC), firearm use (12022.53 PC), great bodily injury (12022.7 PC), and strike priors (667 PC).
If someone involved in the same incident is being offered a much lighter deal (or no charges) in exchange for testifying against you, this is a classic pressure tactic.
If you are facing 20 years but the DA offers 2 years, that gap is a major red flag. The inflated maximum is designed to make the plea seem like a "gift" -- when the charges may not warrant either number.
When the prosecution's key witnesses have their own criminal cases, they may be testifying in exchange for favorable treatment. This is a credibility issue your attorney should raise.
If the officer at the scene wrote it up as a misdemeanor or civil matter, but the DA later filed felony charges, this disconnect can indicate overcharging.
This tool is for educational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Every case is unique, and the law is complex. The patterns identified here are based on common overcharging tactics documented across California. You should discuss these findings with a qualified criminal defense attorney. If you cannot afford an attorney, you have the right to a public defender. Do not make legal decisions based solely on this assessment.
Knowledge is your best defense. Here is what every defendant should know.
Overcharging occurs when a prosecutor files charges that are more serious than the evidence supports, or adds extra charges to create leverage. The goal is not necessarily to convict on every count -- it is to make the defendant so afraid of the maximum sentence that they accept a plea deal without going to trial. A DA might charge a shove as "assault with force likely to cause great bodily injury" (a felony) instead of simple battery (a misdemeanor) -- not because they believe the felony is provable, but because the threat of prison time pressures a plea.
The "trial penalty" is the difference between the sentence a defendant receives after trial versus what they were offered in a plea deal. Studies by the National Association of Criminal Defense Lawyers found that defendants who exercise their constitutional right to trial receive sentences 2 to 6 times longer than those who plead guilty. This effectively punishes people for using the rights the Constitution guarantees them.
2–6x longer sentencesThis is why 97% of federal cases and 94% of state cases end in plea deals. The system is designed to avoid trials.
Charge stacking is when prosecutors file multiple overlapping charges for a single act. Example: one punch in a bar fight can become (1) assault, (2) battery, (3) disturbing the peace, and (4) public intoxication -- four separate counts that carry separate penalties. The purpose is not justice. The purpose is to create a pile of charges so intimidating that the defendant pleads guilty to one or two "lesser" charges rather than risk conviction on all four. California Penal Code 654 prohibits multiple punishments for a single act, but DAs routinely file stacked charges anyway because the stacking happens before sentencing.
Sentencing enhancements can add 1 to 25 years on top of the base sentence. Gang enhancements (PC 186.22) are particularly abused -- defendants are labeled gang members based on where they live, what they wear, or who they know. Firearm enhancements (PC 12022.53) add 10, 20, or 25-to-life even if no one was hurt. California passed SB 620 (2018) giving judges discretion to strike firearm enhancements and SB 81 (2022) requiring judges to dismiss enhancements unless doing so would endanger public safety.
In California, if you are charged with a felony, you have the right to a preliminary hearing within 10 court days of arraignment (unless you waive time). At the prelim, a judge reviews the prosecution's evidence and decides if there is probable cause to hold you for trial. This is your first chance to challenge overcharging -- a judge can dismiss charges or reduce felonies to misdemeanors. Never waive your preliminary hearing without a strategic reason. Your attorney should use it to test the prosecution's case, lock in witness testimony, and expose weak evidence.
The numbers tell the story of a system built on coercion, not justice:
95%+95-97% of criminal cases end in plea deals nationally. In California federal courts, the rate is 97%. Only 2-3% of defendants ever see a jury. Public defenders carry an average of 300-700 cases per year -- the ABA recommends a maximum of 150. When your lawyer has 5 times the recommended caseload, the system's answer is simple: plead guilty and move on. This is not justice. This is processing.
See these tactics in real California cases:
Classic signals: the DA files 5+ counts for a single alleged incident; they charge a "wobbler" (offense that can be filed as felony or misdemeanor) as a felony; they add enhancements disproportionate to the conduct; the plea offer drops charges dramatically (7 counts → 1 count suggests 6 were leverage); the filing doesn't match the police report.
Over 90% of California criminal cases resolve by plea bargain. Overcharging creates a gap between what the DA filed and what they would accept in a plea — that gap is the coercion pressure. A defendant staring at 20 years of exposure will often plead to 3, even if innocent. It's the engine of the plea machine.
Demand the full discovery and the charging-decision memo. At preliminary hearing (PC §859b, see Speedy Trial Checker), the DA must show probable cause for each count — weak counts get dismissed there. File a Marsden motion if your own attorney won't challenge the charging decision.